DISCLAIMER:

The content expressed on this blog reflects the opinion of the author, and does not represent the opinions of any organization with which the author may be affiliated, including the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

Saturday, January 31, 2009

Whose Fault Is It Anyway?

In my last post, I talked about feelings, and how understanding them and being honest with ourselves are the best ways to understand truth. However, recognizing truth is only part of the battle. Knowing what to do with it is often more challenging.

Since every truth is different, they may require different actions. There is no formula on how to appropriately act on truth once we understand it. However, there is one thing that I feel always should accompany any action we make, and that is a willingness to accept personal responsibility.

Now, I might not be the best person to be preaching this sermon on responsibility. Having been married for nearly two years, I have found that one of the greatest perks to marriage is being able to use your spouse as an excuse to get out of something you don’t want to do. My wife and I have both given one another the green light to “pull the spouse card” when we don’t have another legitimate excuse available.

I know this may not be 100% honest. I sleep at night telling myself that this can only be used for small things (don’t want to come over to the neighbor’s house for dinner but don’t want to hurt their feelings, etc.). Pulling the spouse card is one thing, but when making decisions based on truth which is religious or spiritually based, we need to be strong enough to take ownership of our actions and decisions. In other words, we shouldn’t pass off the responsibility to God. Doing this is one example of what the Ten Commandments calls “taking the name of the Lord in vain” (or, as I like to call it, pulling the God card).

Preparing for this post reminded me of an old Saturday Night Live skit called “Pious Housewife.” Sally Field plays a super-religious homemaker who prays to God about everything, and I mean EVERYTHING. Prays for the cast of her favorite day-time TV program, prays that the rice won’t get sticky, etc. Finally, Jesus (Phil Hartman) appears to her. At first she is overjoyed, but she soon learns that he isn’t there to compliment her ability to pray obsessively. He politely explains that although it is good to pray, he would appreciate if she would “tone it down a bit.” It is a good, humorous example of showing how some people don’t use principle of moderation even in religious worship, and how they use God to justify everything in their lives (For the full transcript of the skit, click here).

Pulling the God card and taking the name of the Lord in vain has often led to very tragic consequences. People throughout the centuries have used God as an excuse to kill others, to commit adultery, to abandon their children, or even to start wars.

Other times, people take the name of the Lord in vain because they want something and they don’t think their own efforts will be legitimate enough to gain it. My wife, a proud BYU graduate, has told me college dating stories, where young men would tell her: “I prayed about it, and feel that God wants us to get married/date/whatever.” Seeing as how more than one person used this one on her, it would seem that a lot of independent decision making concerning her life was going on without her even being part of the discussion.

In other circumstances, people use God as an excuse because they are just plain chicken. Using the same example of the Mormon dating scene, how many break-ups have been formalized by pulling the God card. “The Spirit is telling me that we shouldn’t see each other any more.” (Translation: “I don’t really like you but am too big of a wuss to tell you how I really feel.”)

Now, I am not saying that God doesn’t communicate important, life-changing information to us time to time. I have had experiences where I feel very personal and important counsel has been given to me. However, we are ultimately responsible for how we act in response. God gave us agency to choose so that we would develop our own personal sense of responsibility. While we can learn truth from God, we should never use Him as an excuse.

10 comments:

Janet said...

Good thoughts, Nils. You know that the Sally Field SNL episode is one of my favorites. :)

While I've been absent from the forum lately, I haven't lost my ability to offer up an alternative view. ::evil grin::

I no longer believe that good things (or bad) come from a higher power. Events that shape my life result from many influences; some are under my control, some are not. To me, what matters most is how I view my world in light of these circumstances.

I often chuckle when I hear people quickly attribute the "good" things in their lives to God. You can be sure that there will be a football player who makes a touchdown in tomorrow's Super Bowl, and when interviewed on air, he will be thanking God. On the other hand, if the kicker misses a 3-pointer, you aren't likely to hear him report, "God, it's all your fault!"

Here's another example: Say that I have a huge presentation to give at work that has taken me weeks to prepare, and I pull it off without a hitch. The next morning I wake up with a 104 degree fever, muscle aches and shaking chills. I end up in the ER. Do I thank God that He kept me "well" long enough to get though my presentation? Or, do I reason that the stress of the event lowered my immune defenses, and the disease that had invaded my body was finally able to run its course? Blaming God for allowing me to get sick makes just as much sense to me than the first option does (keeping me well just long enough to make it through the presentation).

What I notice almost daily is that people are quick to express gratitude to God for the good things in their lives.

Why are we so unwilling to take full credit for the good things that happen in our lives?

Why is that so uncomfortable for us?

bmillios said...

I just wanted to ask what Emily said when the aforementioned young men pulled the God card on her?

(So I can properly school my teenage daughter, of course.)

Nils Bergeson said...

Janet-

It is great having you back. Hopefully all of our previous comment-makers (and others) will follow your lead and be part of the conversation again.

I think a lot of what you bring up is very relevant, and is a good precursor to the post I am planning to write for next week, pertaining to whether one wears their religion on their sleeve.

I didn't get to see the Superbowl, but were you right? Did somebody say that he played well because God was helping him? Does this mean God is a Steelers fan? Does it mean that Mormonism isn't true because the Utah Jazz have never won an NBA championship and because they happen to be in Utah where there are a lot of Mormons?

Your comments reminded me of one of my favorite George Carlin quotes. You would never hear a football player saying "the good Lord tripped me up behind the line of scrimmage!"

I do think there can be some value of having gratitude in our lives, whether it is gratitude for God (if one believes in Him) or gratitude to others, or just gratitude in general for the good things in our lives. An "attitude of gratitude" is very helpful in cultivating a healthy, positive mental state.

However, I agree that most people who publicly pass off everything to God generally seem to do it for one of two reasons. 1) (as I said in my post) to pass of responsibility. 2) To paint a pious picture of themselves for others. I will talk about this second point more next week. Thank you for your comments! Please keep them coming.

bmilios-

I told Emily of your request for advice, and hopefully you will hear from her soon. Anybody else with these experiences are welcome to comment as well.

Emily said...

Hey Bill... I can tell you right now, just the fact that she's your daughter already makes her fully prepared for whatever curve-balls life throws her. :)

It is hilarious though, when you find yourself face-to-face with such jaw-dropping "logic". Luckily most of my encouters with guys who were "inspired" by god to date or pursue me didn't end up getting too much of a well-thought through response. Guys like this do most of the talking, so after they've exhausted their 'reasoning' you just say "well, see ya later..." You don't have to think about it too much...

tobyo said...

Emily,
Your response cracked me up! Not only because it was simple, but also because I can see it working as well or better than getting into the whole discussion. But... that's very un-O'Hara of you. How did you get this skill? Certainly not from one of us (wink).

Back to the topic at hand:

I'll go ahead and embarrass myself, and those who are also easily embarrassed on my behalf..

I used to offer a silent prayer if I couldn't choose my outfit for the day. Usually an idea would pop right into my head immediately after, and the best part was, I was usually pretty much happy with the 'answer'. In that case, to my mind, it didn't hurt to take this approach because the question and the answer were of little consequence, so even if it was the devil, or the midicloriens, or my own subconscious, at least I was getting an answer quickly, and after taking a moment to agree/disagree, I would proceed to clothe.

I don't do that (much) any more, but I see more fully now that I'm older and wiser how difficult it is to determine which card to pull, and how to go about acting on answers.

For example, it's such a difficult decision whether to move to Australia, how much easier would it be to have an all knowing God come to visit, offer me something to drink, and answer any questions I might have.

Prayer is supposed to be a way of tapping into this infinite knowledge, but a system that is so individualized, and so ambiguous, and so difficult to explain can be easily misunderstood and abused. It is here I fall back on the tried and true maxim that it is the person that is the problem, not God, and not prayer. The kind of person who would pull the God card for ill is simply a weak, flawed, person. Do I chuck prayer because it is misused by a few morons?

I hope not, I still haven't decided on the blue tie or the red tie today.

tyson said...

If I am sick, do I thank God very often for that sickness for allowing me to appreciate times of health? Not very much. If I fail at something even though I prayed and worked really hard does that give me an excuse to blame God? I don't think so. The interpretation of the results of these dilemmas is where we fail at times. I was asked some very good questions on my mission regarding a prophets ability to command nature. This person said that it could have been just a coincidence. I replied that it very well may have been. I then asked them if they believed that God created the earth. The agreed and I said if he could do that then he could very easily control weather and probably even easier communicate the news of the storm early to his prophet. Our perspective on how God is involved in our lives is related to our individualized idea of the nature of God. How much power or control he has in our lives can be attributed to him or not. It still won't change the fact that he loves us and has his hand in all our lives. We are given great power to do many things on our own. We have great bodies that allow us to regenerate and heal. We have trials and great happiness on this planet. God will forever receive my thanks and adoration for this opportunity. If I pray so that I can get a good grade I know he hears and I'll thank him regardless of the outcome. Because if it wasn't for him I wouldn't be here. That's why I'm uncomfortable taking much if any credit for the things I do in my life.

geoffsn said...

This reminded me of the shirts that caused such a stir at BYU: "I can't, I'm Mormon." You gave some great examples of people using the "God card" in your post. I also thought it was interesting how people do this subconsciously. How often do we use some piece of knowledge or truth from God shield us from a moral dilemma? Some items that come to mind are: evidence for evolution, justice for same-sex marriage, stem-cell research, family planning, etc. It's often easy to take some piece of truth from God and say "this ends the entire debate, I no longer have to consider any other implications." Doing this can also hamper our ability to use our agency.

Janet said...

geoffsn said: It's often easy to take some piece of truth from God and say "this ends the entire debate, I no longer have to consider any other implications." Doing this can also hamper our ability to use our agency.

Great point. Reminds me of a bumper sticker I used to see when I lived in the South: "God Said it, I believe it, that settles it." :)

Nils Bergeson said...

Thanks all for your comments.

Tobyo- I hope you were able to decide on a tie. I always thought you looked better in blue.

Although the Phil Hartman/Sally Field skit was humorous, I think it did make a few points, showing how there is indeed a more proper way to use prayer. Asking for assistance in important things in life (like the daughter's Algebra test) are not inconsequential. Of course, there are even bigger questions, like "should I move to Australia." It would be nice to have the absolute answers on a lot of these things.

I think answers to prayers come in all sorts of varieties. While a clear "yes" or "no" might be our fancy, I think God has probably given the answer "It's up to you," far more than either of the others.

Tyson-

Thanks for your thoughts on why you give thanks to God for help in different things. I remember one of the most special moments of my life is when I had a task that felt insurmountable for me, and praying for help. Seeing how easily I was able to accomplish the task that had before seemed so impossible brought on one of the deepest feelings of gratitude I have ever felt.

I recently was in a job interview, and one of the questions led me to talk about a time when I participated as a member of a team (not just an individual accomplishment) to get something done. Sometime in the future, I would like to write something about the value of collectivism (instead of focusing so intensely on individualism, as Americans tend to do often). This could be helping one another, or working together with God to accomplish something.

Geoffsn-

The idea that using God as an excuse in any action we do to "close the argument" is often a major hampering factor to our agency is spot on in my opinion. Thanks.

Roly said...

As to the question,"should I move to Australia", the answer is "Yes Nils, you and Emily absolutely should" after sadly many people loosing their lives in the bush fires, there is room for you both and your impending family. I received revelation on it for you just the other day! wink...

If only we get absolute answers for all our questions it would make my life a lot easier, but as to enjoying life more in the long term maybe not. When you are a kid, you have to do what your parents say, sometimes you like it sometimes you don't.

Then you become an adult and go wow... that is all the stuff my parents had to do and decide.... we then become much more appreciative of them and start to worry about all the choices we have to make for our own children.

We make choices and hope for the best. Some are certainly more important than others. I think sometimes members work in absolutes... if I do this then this will be the result, see here it says so, he promised!

This is a little cut and dry for me from my life experience thus far, I find the Lord has a lot less diamonds and rocks and a lot more garnets, amethysts, ruby's, marble, granite.... many varieties some more appealing to some than others, and we don't always get our preference.

As to prayer - if only I had the time for all the intricate answers some people claim to get, for their everyday lives.

With all things the more you put into it the more you get out of it, or so they say!