Sunday, September 12, 2010

Understanding Islam

Today, per reader request, I write some about a religion other than Mormonism. With today being the 9-year anniversary of the September 11th, 2001 attacks on the United States, and with recent related controversies in the United States, including the proposed Islamic Center planned to be built near the site of the World Trade Center and the Florida pastor who had proclaimed “burn a Quran day,” I look forward to sharing thoughts on one of the most fascinating religious belief systems in the world – Islam.

A particular memory from my mission still stands out vividly in my mind. As some of you may know, I was a missionary in Russia from 2002-2004. What some of you may not know is that Islam is the second largest religion in that country, with an estimated 16 million plus Muslims living in Russia, making up about 12% of the population. Islam is considered one of Russia’s four traditional religions, along with Orthodox Christianity, Judaism, and Buddhism.

On one particular summer’s day, which happened to be our missionary preparation day, another missionary asked if I would be interested in accompanying him to an Uzbek market on the outskirts of town. It was fascinating to visit this cultural enclave of Russia, where an unfamiliar language was being spoken, and where agricultural and other products imported from Central Asia were being sold. At one end of the market stood a modest wooden Mosque. Our curiosity piqued, we ventured over to the mosque to have a look.

The mosque’s imam, a middle-aged Uzbek man in traditional Muslim dress, was very cordial, and invited us to come and sit with him on the mosque’s veranda. After taking off our shoes, we sat on the padded floor, and commenced having an enlightening discussion with the religious leader. Four or five other men, some former imams themselves, joined us, and answered our questions about their religion, including sharing experiences such as the Hajj, or Muslim pilgrimage to Mecca. They also asked us questions about our religion as well, including how we viewed Isa (Arabic name for Jesus), and the role of prophets.

Some time into our discussion, the call for prayer came. It was my first experience with a Muslim prayer call, and I remember being fascinated as one of the older men recited the prayer in Arabic in an almost song-like tone over the loudspeakers so that every corner of the market could hear.

Since that experience, I have been fortunate to have had many other which have exposed me further to Islam. I have visited Muslim countries (I haven’t yet had the opportunity to live in one yet – but I have my eye on Egypt, Jordan, and Kazakhstan), visited and admired a number of beautiful mosques, and made dozens of Muslim friends from all over the world.

What saddens me, however, is seeing the ongoing prejudice Muslims face in the United States. While I certainly share no sympathy with religious extremists of any sort, including terrorists who manipulate religion to serve their own dastardly and cowardly purposes, I can’t help but regret all the anti-Islam sentiment that I see burning bright in my home country.

This anti-Islamic fear and prejudice, like most prejudices, comes from a clear lack of understanding and exposure. It is a classic example of the “fear of the unknown.”

There are many who still believe that a majority of Muslims are anti-American, and in their hearts they support the acts of terrorism carried out against the USA and other countries by Muslim extremists. There is no notion that could be more dead wrong – period.

Often, when I see this point made by others, I hear a common response. “Have you actually read the Quran? Do you realize that it supports acts of violence against non-Muslims?”

As a matter of fact, I have read it. I read it as a missionary, wanting to gain a better understanding of the Muslims with whom I interacted on a nearly daily basis. While it is true that some passages of this book could be interpreted as such, my answer to critics is, “Could not passages of the Bible be interpreted in a similar way?”

The fact is, extremism, whether religious, anti-religious, or of any other kind, is the true evil in the world. People have tapped into extremism of all sorts in order to justify terrible actions throughout every chapter in history.

Nevertheless, we are more likely to notice extremism coming from those who do not believe like us. Would there have ever been a controversy in the building of a Christian church near the site of the Oklahoma City bombing? Why not? Did not the terrorists in that attack act based on notions of Christian extremism?

In contrast to Islam, we as Americans have all been exposed to Christianity in its true sense. The majority of us claim to be Christian, and so it is easy for us to recognize that some fringe group doing terrible things in the name of Jesus does not represent all of Christianity.

Is it not conceivable that the same principle applies to Islam? The vast majority (and when I say majority, I don’t mean like 55%, I’m talking like 99.999999999999% here) of Muslims are opposed to terrorism, and are insulted by those who take Allah’s name in vain through such acts. Yet because Muslims are still a largely hidden minority in the United States, and because most of our exposure to “Islam” through the media is either related to terrorism or turmoil in the Middle East, we have created a very false picture of what Islam is in our minds.

Rather than entertaining such a false and harmful paradigm, I encourage you all to seek a deeper understanding of what Islam actually is. You don’t have to become a Muslim or believe in everything they believe to appreciate them. But I encourage you to seek out your local Islamic community center or other means of learning. I promise you that Muslims you meet will be very happy to share their identity with you. For one, hospitality plays a very prominent role in Islamic culture. Secondly, they are the direct recipients of the negative consequences of ignorance and bigotry, so they tend to be quite eager to clear up misconceptions about who they are (does this sound like any other religious group you know of?).

I promise you, that if we as Mormons and as Americans will take a proactive role in understanding and appreciating Islam, the world will be a vastly better place. We won’t need to worry about relatively meaningless arguments such as whether an Islamic Center should be built in a certain place, or whether some pastor is acting within his first amendment rights to burn the Quran. Rather, we will recognize that all are God’s children, and that our imposing upon them a false identity based on the actions of others is wrong.

17 comments:

jesssse said...

While I'm an atheist, and this is kind of tangentially related to your post, I thought this would be a good opportunity to share this cool video I took in Bangalore, India: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktf_hRtlgc0.

Rick said...

Well said, Nils.

Tiffany said...

While I appreciate your views, I experienced some completely different experiences than you have with Islam.

I spent to weeks in Egypt and Jordan. The government in Jordan keeps a pretty tight leash on extremism in their country. Most peopel were cordial.

I found that to be completly opposite in Egypt. If I was not walking right next to my husband I was called a whore, infadel and pig. I had bottle caps thrown at me along with rocks. I went to Queen Hatshepsut's temple and saw the bullet holes left from terrorists killing 66 Germans a year before. It was chilling as there was no where to hide. From there we went to a place where they make hand made alabaster vases. I went to the back without my husband. I got corned and told how much Egyptian's hate Americans and that the wished the same to me as what had happened to the 66 Germans. I was very scared and upset by this. I did not ever feel completly safe in Egypt.

I have read the Koran two times. It tells about horrible things to do to people that do not obey. It states in one verse; "If you are not well please with your wife, take her out and beat her." They live the old law and women are as shattle.

When I went to Israel we were very welcomed in the Mosques. We went to the Al Aqsa mosque and it was very beautiful. The man in charge was charming. They aslo build mosques over countries they try to dominate. That is why the mosque is built over Soloman's temple. That is whey they want to build a mosque where the twin towers used to stand.

I know many wonderul Islamic people and I found that the least educated, the more likely they were to hate Americans and be extremists. Those that are educated are much more secular and excepting of others. There countries are so poor many are educated or I would say brain washed to hate America as we are the whore of the earth.

jesssse said...

Tiffany, I can't help but reply to your comment. It is a shame that you had to experience what you did in Egypt, but I feel like you could potentially experience similar behavior from any religion.

Now to your other points. "They" don't want to build a mosque over the World Trade Center site. "They" want to build a community center, which would include a prayer room, a few blocks from the World Trade Center. This location currently houses a Muslim prayer room, and used to house a...Burlington Coat Factory. I was across the street from the proposed community center site this morning, and even on the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, I felt really far removed from the World Trade Center site. And you probably aren't aware of this, but the community center has been planned for over a year, and it wasn't until a bunch of right-wing extremists realized it would be a great political wedge, that it was brought to national attention.

As for your last paragraph, I think it just serves to highlight the importance of education. Ignorace due to lack of education is not exclusive to the Islamic world. I think the same phenomenon has been manifesting itself quite well recently in the U.S.

And second-to-lastly, as Nils said, there are some pretty reprehensible things in the bible as well. If it weren't for the irrationality of a belief in god, that would be my main motivation for being an atheist.

Finally, I think this is a great article that you'll hopefully read: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/11/nyregion/11religion.html.

P.S. I'm in no condition right now to re-read this or spell-check anything, so it might not be the most coherent comment.

Tracy said...

Nils, I enjoyed your article and I too believe that we should "all get along" in this world and practice any religion we please, or no religion at if that's what makes us happy. I do disagree with your statement, though, on Timothy McVeigh's terrorism. As far as I have been able to find, he was angry at our government for not upholding the constitution and did not commit his terrorism in the name of God or for any Christian principals, and in fact claimed to be agnostic in several interviews. The Islamic extremists, on the other hand, attacked in the name of Allah and for their religion. So those particular incidents are quite different. There are many examples of Christians trying to destroy or conquer in for their religions, but I don't believe the Oklahoma City bombing is one of them.

Janet said...

Nils, this is a beautiful post.

Tiffany, I am also sorry that you had a negative experience in Egypt. I can only imagine how frightening it was for you. However, I struggle to believe that it is the "norm." One of my fondest memories as a nurse was assisting an Egyptian woman with her newborn. She and I related in a way that I wish was more common to the human experience. I still think of her from time to time and hope things are going well for her.

Religious oppression takes many different forms - some more subtle than others - but it's insidious, very much alive and well in many Christian faiths as well. As demonstrated by your experience, women are very often the victims of this oppression.

And just as jessse and Nils said, violence is found throughout the Bible (and in the BOM as well). There are many accounts of cruelity and vindictiveness. It was something that I could never wrap my brain around when I was a believer.

jesssse said...

Tracy, I think you're right about McVeigh, but from what I've read, Bin Laden's main motivation for the 9/11 attacks was the presence of U.S. troops in Saudia Arabia.

Tracy said...

jesssse- good point about Bin Laden! Maybe he and McVeigh should just be considered psychotics instead of religious extremists.

Nils Bergeson said...

Thanks to everybody for your comments. You actually bring up a good point that I wanted to make earlier concerning motives of terrorism.

While it's true that many act in the name of God, I believe that acts of terrorism are generally carried out for primarily political or social reasons. When religion gets introduced, it is general used as a justification or a recruitment tool.

I remember taking a class, sociology of religion, when I was in college, and going over a study which attempted to measure the connection between religion and prejudice. The original hypothesis of the study was that religious belief would positively correlate with discrimination and prejudice against others.

What was found, however, surprised the researchers. They discovered that prejudice was highest among those who claimed to be religious, but did not actively particpate in the life of the religion or live according to the religion's principles. The least prejudice were those who actively lived their religion, with non-religious people in between the two.

While obviously these were just averages and there are always individuals who don't follow the pattern, I imagine a lot of terrorists as fitting this model. They claim religion where it suits their purposes (whether politcal, individual, nationalistic, etc.) but tend not to live according to the established principles as set forth by their religion.

Nils Bergeson said...

I'm glad some people have brought up the question of whether the Qur'an encourages violence or not. This is something I wished to elaborate on more, but didn't to save time.

Take for instance this passage:

"I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve. Therefore strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them" (Qur'an 8:12)

This an other passages like this have been used by extremists/terrorists and anti-Islamists alike to show how Islam supposedly promotes/condones violence.

The same criticism has been made of the bible, giving verses such as this:

"2 If there be found among you ... that hath wrought wickedness in the sight of the Lord thy God ...
3 And hath gone and served other gods, and worshipped them ...
4 And it be told thee, and thou hast heard of it, and enquired diligently, and, behold, it be true, and the thing certain...
5 Then shalt thou bring forth that man or that woman, which have committed that wicked thing ... and shalt stone them with stones, till they die." (Deuteronomy 17:2-5)

I think it is important when reading any religious text to understand a number of things.

1) The context: What were the historical/social norms at the time of the writing? Is the verse referring to some specific incident? Are there other qualifiers?

2) What is the "bigger picture?" My impression of the Qur'an, when I read it, was that it was an overall message of peace. I feel the same when I read the Bible, Book of Mormon, or other religious texts, despite some of the verses which suggest otherwise.

The 8th article of Faith in Mormon belief says: "We believe the Bible to be the word of God as far as it is translated correctly."

Often, when we read this, I think we assume it means the linguistic accuracy of the translation of the words contained therein. I think it goes a step further as well. When we make our personal interpretations as to what passages mean, we need to interpret them correctly.

Nils Bergeson said...

Tiffany -

I too am sorry to hear you had such a bad experience in Egypt. It sounds to me, however, that the intolerance against Americans is more of a political/social prejudice, rather than a religious one (correct me if I'm wrong).

I have faced similar anti-American sentiments in other countries as well, including receiving death threats from extremists while living in Russia. It certainly is an uncomfortable feeling, so I sympathize completely with the feeling. However, do you believe that the anti-American/Western people in Egypt act primarily based on their religion, or do they just also happen to live in a country where everybody is Muslim?

I also have to disagree with your comment:

"They aslo (sic) build mosques over countries they try to dominate. That is why the mosque is built over Soloman's (sic) temple. That is whey they want to build a mosque where the twin towers used to stand."

jesssse responded to this already, but who is the "they" that you are referring to? If you mean "The Muslims," I invite you to clarify and revise your statement.

I think the belief that the Islamic Community Center to be built in New York City is a sign of "domination" is completely ridiculous, with all due respect. I invite everybody to read this article as well:

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/08/opinion/08mosque.html?_r=2&ref=opinion

In addition, I invite you to read a blog post by a friend of mine on this subject which I think articulates why the Islamic Cultural Center is not only within our constitutional rights as Americans, but actually a fantastic idea.

http://slammysworld.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-will-we-be-remembered.html

Nils Bergeson said...

I wanted to leave one more note for Tracy -

Upon further research, I figured out that you were right. Timothy McVeigh, who carried out the Oklahoma City bombing, never claimed religious motives for the attack.

It wasn't the best example to use, and I apologize for using it.

It could be noted, however, that we tend to automatically see Islam as the primary identity of those who carried out the 9/11 attacks. Often, when some aspect of another individual (whether race, nationality, religion, etc.) is different than ours, it is easy to group them and others into one pile.

What then was Timothy McVeigh's primary identity? White? Male? Twenty-something? Anti-government? I'd probably say the latter, but since there isn't a neat and tidy "Anti-government" group to classify, it's hard to then hold prejudices against them.

Anyway, my ultimate point is simply that we should judge any group by their weakest link. If that is the case, than nobody on earth is safe...

Iuliana Blakely said...

Thank you for your post. Loved it. Although I agree with all that you've said, I haven't been very proactive in learning about Muslims. I have lots of Muslim friends and love them a ton. I will definitely seek out to learn more. I am inspired to do so thanks to your post. Keep'em coming:)

Tiffany said...

Please read this and let me know what you think? As history has shown the opposite of you say they are not doing. Which is building mosques to show dominan. It doesn't matter that they are calling it "Community Center" I truly believe that it is still a mosque plain and simple.

http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/id.5594/pub_detail.asp

http://polipundit.com/?p=25538

I also think you have a different prespective because you are male. You are much more valued than a woman. I was safe as long as I was next to my husband it was when I was at least 5 or more feet aways from him that my problems occured. Also not one woman spoke to me in Egypt as they did not want to pay the price later.

Brad Carmack said...

Hey Nils! I'm looking into the foreign service- I have my oral exam in February.

Would you like to guest post the below?

Thank you,

Brad Carmack
2011 JD/MPA Candidate

Title: Homosexuality: A Straight BYU Student’s Perspective
1) President Packer’s general conference talk
2) The recent rash of suicides by gay teens across the country, accompanying “It Gets Better Project,” and current suffering of my homosexually oriented brothers and sisters
3) My coauthor, from whom I have received much help and inspiration, wants it out sooner than later
These are the reasons why I am releasing my book now. I preferred to wait until Homosexuality: A Straight BYU Student’s Perspective was groomed and edited further; however, it is not my book alone. Heavenly Father helped me write it, and I believe He would have me release it rather than keep it on my hard drive while I spend months making minor improvements. This book is destined to relieve some of the suffering of my homosexual brothers and sisters, though I don’t yet know by how much. Stuart Matis, shortly before committing suicide on the steps of an LDS chapel on February 25, 2000 in Los Altos, California, wrote to his family: “Perhaps my death ... might become the catalyst for much good. I'm sure that you will now be strengthened in your resolve to teach the members and the leaders regarding the true nature of homosexuality. My life was actually killed many years ago. Your actions might help to save many young people's lives."

So here it is- my 165-page magnum opus to date, in raw .docx and .pdf form (google doc: https://docs.google.com/leaf?id=0B1u3K43P-3JoYTUzNjYwMGEtNzNmYi00ODkwLTllMzYtNjRlOTVlMWUwYTM2&hl=en
Non gmail users, in .pdf only:
http://rapidshare.com/files/426861209/Homosexuality_A_Straight_BYU_Student_s_Perspective_Draft_2.pdf). I invite your feedback as I’m still in the later editing stage. Summary of the book below.

My promise to the open-minded reader is that you will be touched, you will learn things you had never considered, and your views on same-sex marriage and homosexuality in the LDS church will likely change voluntarily.

-Bradley Carmack

Brad Carmack said...

Summary: The book has two parts: 1) homosexuality (chapters 1-3) and 2) same-sex marriage (chapters 4-7).

In chapter 1, I argue that church members should have great compassion for homosexually oriented members of the church because of the personal difficulties they experience as a result of their orientation and how the Mormon community typically responds to that orientation. I quote a number of studies and give voice to the experiences of many LDS homosexually oriented people.

In chapter 2, I explore causation, detailing both the religious voice and the scientific consensus. Elder Oaks noted how appropriate this type of an inquiry is: "The Church does not have a position on the causes of any of these susceptibilities or inclinations, including those related to same-gender attraction. Those are scientific questions — whether nature or nurture — those are things the Church doesn’t have a position on." I detail 60 statements by church leaders on what causes homosexuality. On the scientific side, I discuss 32 separate subjects to juxtapose two opposing hypotheses for the causation of homosexual orientation: 1) biological factors such as genes and pre-natal hormones, and 2) factors such as infection, molestation, and choice. Some examples of the evidence addressed: homosexual men have, on average, measurably and significantly different ratios of the second to fourth digit of their hands than their heterosexual counterparts. The anterior commissure of their brains is gender shifted away from the heterosexual male norm and toward the heterosexual female norm. Their limb:trunk ratio is similarly gender-shifted, as is their performance on visio-spatial tasks, third interstitial nucleus (a region of the brain thought to be directive of male-type sexual behavior) size and density, left:right brain hemisphere ratio, brain response to sex pheromones, cochlear sound production, thalamic response to female faces, verbal abilities, physical aggressiveness, expressiveness, and childhood gender conformity to name just a few.

In chapter 3 I examine how changeable sexual orientation is by considering relevant church doctrines and looking at the empirical evidence on both sides.

In chapter 4 I show why homosexuals can reproduce, contrary to popular belief, and note that they are no different from inherently infertile heterosexual couples as to their reproductive capacity.

In chapter 5 I argue why, assuming for a moment that homosexual behavior is not sinful, it makes a lot of moral sense to support LDS same-sex marriage. For instance, I show how important family is to mortal experience and point out that celibacy does not provide a family experience, while same-sex marriage does.

Chapter 6 contains rebuttals to common anti- same-sex marriage arguments, many of which are deeply flawed.

Chapter 7 applies Elder Oaks's recent speech on the Constitution. Many church members have said that Judge Walker should not have heard the Perry v. Schwarzenegger (Prop 8) case, but instead should have let the voice of the people of California decide the matter. I show why this view is antithetical to our constitutional system of governance.

In closing, I explain my motivations for writing and make invitations to the reader.

____________________________________________________

Bio:
Brad Carmack is in his last year of the JD/MPA program at BYU. He majored in Biology, performed clerk assignments for Justice Joel Horton of the Idaho Supreme Court, and is currently a teacher’s assistant for Human Resources Law and Bioethics. Brad also regularly participates in USGA [Understanding Same Gender Attraction], an unsponsored BYU student talk group.

Nate said...

Nils,

I enjoyed your post. I served my mission in the West Indies and had the opportunity to meet and become friends with many Islamic people as well. There were a few that were hostile towards us but for the most part they were friendly and inviting. I also read the Qur'an on my mission. It saddens me as well to see fellow Americans group all of them together with a small group of people.

DISCLAIMER:

The content expressed on this blog reflects the opinion of the author(s), and does not represent the opinions of any organization with which the author may be affiliated, including the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.